Saturday, November 21, 2020

Ordinary Grace, by William Kent Krueger

 

Characters

Nathan and Ruth Drum

Frank – narrator

Ariel

Jake

 

Grandfather and Liz (second wife)

 

Gus – served with Nathan during the war

 

Brandt Family:

Emil – Ruth’s former fiancĂ©, blinded in war, musician

Lise – sister, deaf

Axel and Julia - Emil and Lise’s brother and wife

Karl – son, Ariel’s boyfriend

 

Police:

Doyle

Blake

Gregor – county sheriff

 

Danny O’Keefe – friend of Frank’s

Warren Redstone – Indian sitting with “Skipper’s” body when Frank found them, had Bobby Cole’s glasses

 

Morris Engdahl – bully

 

Mrs.  Klement – alto in choir, came to Nathan for marital counseling

Peter – son, Frank’s age

Travis – husband, abusive

 

Avis and Edna Sweeney – neighbors, Frank spied on Edna’s laundry on line, came to Nathan for marital counseling

 

Bobby Cole – first death

“Skipper” – itinerant, second death

 

For Discussion:

NOTE: Page numbers are from the paperback edition.

1.       Was it realistic to expect Ruth to make the transition from her expectation of being the wife of a successful lawyer to being a minister’s wife?

2.       Given that Nathan was a minister, God and faith were featured prominently in the book. Do you agree with that statement?   Do you think a Christian would read the book differently than a non-Christian?

3.       Frank thought that Jake “often took the measure of a situation and of people much more accurately than others might have” (page 200).  Why was that?

4.       Why did Jake’s stuttering go away after he said an “ordinary grace” at Ariel’s funeral luncheon?

5.       Why do you think Lise and Jake had such a special relationship and could communicate with each other?

6.       Was Frank responsible for helping to solve things or did he cause more trouble by always ease dropping and spying on people?

7.       Was Frank and/or Doyle partially responsible for Karl’s death because they shared private information between Karl and Nathan?

8.       Was Officer Doyle one of the few evil characters in the book?  Consider that he told others about the confidential conversation between Nathan and Karl and also blew up the frog with the firecracker in front of Frank.

9.       What did you think about Gus?  Did you like his character?  How important was his friendship to Nathan?  Were you surprised he played such an important part in the story?

10.   As you read, what were your thoughts and suspicions about Ruth, Emil and Ariel?  How was Nathan able to be so accepting of Ruth going to stay with Emil after Ariel’s death?

11.   The story was written from Frank’s perspective, 40 years later.  Regarding Engdahl, Frank thought, “Now, forty years later, I realize that what I saw was a kid not all that much older than me…blind and lost…I probably should have felt for him something other than I did which was hatred” (page 10).  Would it have been possible for Frank to see Engdahl differently at his young age? 

12.   On page 306, Frank said what he has learned from studying history is that there is, “no such thing as a true event…accounts of what happened depend upon the perspectives from which the event is viewed.”  How do you think some of the other characters would have told this story?

13.   Did you like the way the story ended?

*****

First Semester Success, 2nd edition, by Dr. Arden B. Hamer, is available at amazon.com and wordassociation.com.  

Interpreter of Maladies, by Jhumpa Lahiri

 

A Temporary Matter

Shoba – rented her own apartment, did not tell Shukumar

 

Shukumar – working from home, held deceased baby, never told Shoba

Why did the darkness make such a difference in their relationship?

 

Do you think they stayed together?

When Mr. Pirzada Came to Dine

Mr. Pirzada – wife and 7 daughters in Dacca which was invaded by Pakistan

 

Lilia

Parents

 

What did the author want the reader to take away from this story?

Interpreter of Maladies

Mr. and Mrs. Das

Children – Tina, Bobby, Ronny

 

Mr. Kapasi – tour guide, interpreter at doctor’s office

Why did Mrs. Das confide in Mr.  Kapasi?

The Real Durwan

Boori Ma – unofficial durwan of apartment building

 

Mr. and Mrs. Dalal – Mr. Dalal promoted, bought things for building

 

Mr. Chatterjee

 

Mrs. Misra

Why did the tenants blame Boori Ma for the damage done to the building? 

Sexy

Laxmi – Indian

 

Miranda – American,

Dev – affair with Miranda, married

 

Laxmi’s cousin – husband ran off with woman he met on airplane

Rohin - son

 

Was Miranda’s behavior with Rohin appropriate?

 

Why did Miranda end her affair with Dev?

Mrs. Sen’s

Mother

Eliot

 

Mr. Sen – professor

Mrs. Sen – babysat Eliot in her home

 

Do you think Mrs. Sen will ever find happiness in America?

 

Would you have felt comfortable leaving your child with Mrs. Sen?

This Blessed House

Tanima “Twinkle”

Sanjeev

Why was Twinkle so connected with the Christian items left in the house?

The Treatment of Bibi Haldar

Bibi Halder – coached by neighborhood women on how to be more feminine

Son

 

Halder cousin – owner of cosmetics shop, blamed Bibi for daughter’s illness

Wife

Daughter

Why did Bibi’s cousin blame her for the daughter’s illness?

 

What do you think happened to Bibi that she was cured at the end of the story?

The Third and Final Continent

Narrator

Mala – wife

Son

 

Mrs. Craft - landlady

Helen - daughter

This was the only story that tells the reader what happens in the end.  Is this a good story for the last one?  Did you find it satisfying?

 

For Discussion:

1.       In the Forward to the 20th anniversary edition of the book, the reviewer wrote of the stories in the book, “their cohabitation makes perfect sense” (page xi).  Was there a theme or connection among all of the stories?

2.       What was your reading experience with short stories compared to novels?

3.       Did your feel connected with the characters or did you want to have them developed more fully?

4.       Did any of the stories help you to think differently or give you a greater understanding of someone living in a different country than where they were born?

5.       Why did this book win the Pulitzer Prize in 2000?

*****

First Semester Success, 2nd edition, by Dr. Arden B. Hamer, is available at amazon.com and wordassociation.com.