Monday, March 31, 2025

All the Colors of the Dark, by Chris Whitaker

 

Characters

“Patch” Joseph Macauley

Ivy – mother

 

Saint – career in law enforcement, devoted much of life to finding Patch

Norma – grandmother

 

Misty Meyer – Patch saved her from attack

Mary - grandmother

 

Chief Nix

 

Dr. Tooms – in jail for taking girls

 

Eli Aaron – photographer, did high school pictures – admitted to taking girls, stabbed Patch and help captive

Grace – daughter, visited Patch when he was held by Aaron

 

Jimmy Walters – married to Saint

 

Sammy – Monta Clare Fine Art – displayed and sold Patch’s paintings, gave him studio space to paint

 

Candice and Nicholas Addis – adopted Theodore, Saint and Jimmy’s child (although Saint told Jimmy she had an abortion)

 

Charlotte -daughter of Misty and Patch

Timeline of the sections

1975 – 1 and 2

1976

1978

1982

1983

·       Patch searching for Grace across country.  Robbing banks.  Saint found, shot him and he ended in jail.

1990

·       Misty died of cancer, gave Patch sole custody of Charlotte

1995

·       Aaron alive – bought more rosary beads

1998

·       Patch in jail for punching and accidentally killing Jimmy Walters, escaped

·       Rearrested at Aaron’s barn by Saint after he shot Aaron to save her

·       Saint – Chief of Monta Clare Police Department

2001

·       Patch missing, on sailboat in Outer Banks

For Discussion:

NOTE: Page numbers are from the hardback edition.

1.       There were a lot of characters in the novel.   Which ones did you find most interesting?  How did you keep everyone straight?

2.       After Patch saved Misty and he was rescued, she kept wanting to be with him.   After a while he told her, “You’ve done it now Misty.  You reached out and I’m grateful and all…It’s just a reminder that things aren’t right with your world” (page 80).  She asked what she should do, and Patch answered, “you go back to your side of the street, Misty” (page 80).  Do you think she was relieved or sad to finally quit and move on?

3.       What did you think of Sammy and his art gallery?  He encouraged Patch to paint and then eventually Charlotte.

4.       What did you think about Marty Tooms, the doctor.   Where you surprised to read that he really was innocent except for doing secret abortions to help the high school girls?  Were you also surprised to learn that he was in a relationship with Chief Nix?

5.       The author lives in London. Being from Pittsburgh, what did you think when you read the reference to Mister Rogers, Lady Aberlin and Joe Negri on page 163.   The author obviously felt they had world-wide appeal and would be recognized by anyone.  Do you think the reference was taken differently by Pittsburghers compared to other readers not from this area?

6.       There was a lot about loss in this novel.  For example, on page 68, when talking with her grandmother, “Saint wanted to ask what it was like, to lose the thing that defined you.  But perhaps she knew: it left you someone else.”  Did this offer any insights to your thinking about loss?  How did this play out in the rest of the story?  Who else experienced loss – or did no one in the book escape it?

7.       Did you like the part where Patch escaped from jail with the help of all the people working there who were connected to the missing girls that he helped find?  (Owen Williams who cut power line was Lucy’s father, Patch found Cooper Strike’s missing sister and brought her home.)

8.       In chapters 252 and 253, Patch shot Aaron to save Saint who then arrested him, probably because he was an escapee.  What do you think happened between then and 2001 when Patch was in the sailboat?

9.       If he could have, do you think Patch would have gone back to Grace?

10.   What was your reading experience?  Did you sometimes skip ahead, maybe at some point read the ending?  Did you have trouble keeping the characters, the dead girls, and their parents straight?  Could the book have been shorter?

11.   Why is this book so popular?

No comments:

Post a Comment